Toyota leads CarEdge’s five-year resale value rankings with 64.9% average value retention, ahead of Subaru and Honda. But the individual vehicle rankings reveal a different winner: two American heavy-duty pickups outperform the Toyota Tacoma.
Depreciation can substantially change the actual cost of owning a vehicle. A lower purchase price does not necessarily mean lower ownership costs if a vehicle loses much of its value before being sold or traded in. CarEdge’s five-year depreciation rankings offer a comparison of how different brands and models retain their original value.
Toyota ranks first among the brands evaluated, retaining an estimated 64.9% of its original value after five years. That represents depreciation of 35.1%. Subaru follows at 61.2%, while Honda takes third place at 60.5%. Toyota’s advantage over Subaru amounts to 3.7 percentage points, although individual models can perform considerably better or worse than their brand averages.
Tacoma Retains 78.4%, but Two Heavy-Duty Trucks Rank Higher
The Toyota Tacoma is one of the strongest performers in CarEdge’s model rankings, with an estimated five-year residual value of 78.4%. That means the midsize pickup loses approximately 21.6% of its original value over the period.
However, the Tacoma does not lead the overall vehicle rankings. The GMC Sierra 3500HD takes first place with 80.3% retained value, followed by the Chevrolet Silverado 3500HD at 78.4%. The Tacoma ranks third, with the same displayed percentage as the Chevrolet.
This distinction matters when interpreting Toyota’s resale reputation. Toyota leads at the brand level, but General Motors’ heavy-duty pickups occupy the first two positions in CarEdge’s individual model rankings. The results also show that strong resale performance is not limited to Toyota vehicles.
Toyota’s Sports Cars Also Hold Their Value
The Tacoma is not Toyota’s only vehicle near the top of the rankings. CarEdge assigns both the Toyota GR86 and GR Supra five-year residual values of 76.9%, placing them fourth and fifth overall.
The Corolla Hatchback follows with 76.7%, while the 4Runner retains an estimated 74.9%. Toyota’s full-size Tundra also performs strongly, with a five-year residual value of 74.0%.
Honda Passport Baja Spec Packs 1,300 HP for 2027 Desert Racing, but It’s No Ordinary Passport SUV
These results show considerable variation within Toyota’s lineup. The brand’s sports cars, midsize pickup, body-on-frame SUV and full-size pickup all outperform its overall 64.9% average. The Corolla Hatchback also demonstrates that strong projected resale values are not exclusive to trucks and performance cars.
RAV4 and Corolla Offer Stronger Retention Than Toyota’s Brand Average
For buyers considering more conventional transportation, the Toyota RAV4 retains an estimated 72.5% of its original value after five years, according to CarEdge. The Corolla sedan retains 67.3%.
Both exceed Toyota’s brand average, although neither approaches the Tacoma’s result. The difference illustrates why depreciation comparisons are more useful when conducted at the model level rather than relying entirely on a manufacturer’s reputation.
CarEdge also places the Honda Civic and CR-V at 71.0% retained value, providing additional context for buyers comparing compact cars and SUVs. Under this methodology, the RAV4 performs better than the CR-V, while the Corolla sedan trails the Civic.
What the Rankings Mean for Used-Car Buyers
Strong resale value benefits owners who eventually sell or trade in their vehicles, but it creates a different situation for used-car shoppers. A vehicle that depreciates slowly may offer less of a discount compared with its original purchase price.
The rankings are estimates rather than guaranteed resale prices. An individual vehicle’s market value depends on factors including model year, trim, mileage, condition, accident history and local demand. The published percentages should not be interpreted as firm offers from dealerships or predictions of what every owner will receive.
CarEdge’s figures also represent five-year residual values, not an annual depreciation rate. A vehicle retaining 78.4% after five years has not necessarily lost value at an equal rate each year.
For shoppers comparing new and used Toyotas, the practical distinction is straightforward: models such as the Tacoma and 4Runner may preserve more of their purchase price for an eventual seller, while buyers searching for a heavily depreciated used vehicle may find smaller savings than expected.
